Apple’s Use of ‘Face ID’ Could Result in a Lawsuit
Apple may be the first tech company to equip a smartphone with a facial recognition platform as advanced as “Face ID.” But the company is not the first to use the term “Face ID,” or even trademark it.
A small company called FingerTec has been using the name “Face ID” for a line of door access hardware with facial and fingerprint biometric security. It’s not clear how long the Malaysia-based company has been using the term, but the company itself has been around since at least 2005.
According to U.S. Patent and Trademark Office records, there are three existing trademarks for the phrase “Face ID.” All three are currently owned by a company called TMT Technologies apparently based in Dover, Delaware. Specifically, one of those trademarks relates to “computer hardware and software for use in biometric authentication.” That trademark was filed in February 2017. TMT Technologies also has a trademark on Face ID relating to information technology consulting services.
Interestingly, the oldest trademark on Face ID seems to originate from a San Diego-based biometrics company called ImageWare Software, Inc., but is now owned by TMT Technologies as well. The trademark relates to facial recognition and retrieval software for “law enforcement applications.” Additionally, this is a registered trademark, unlike the others, and was first filed for in February 1998.
Additionally, a trademark protects the source of a product or service. In these cases, a trademark must either be inherently unique, or it must protect a product that is itself distinctive. A company suing Apple would have to prove in court that the general public identities or associates the term “Face ID” with their company and product, rather than Apple or its product, and that Apple’s use of the term would cause confusion.
That gets tricky since TMT Technologies, LLC is an obscure company. They don’t seem to have any forward-facing consumer products. Even the address listed on their trademark appears to belong to an company called NRAI Services, which is unrelated to the tech field. On the other hand, TMT Technologies’ trademark specifically relates to facial recognition software.
So even though Apple doesn’t currently hold a trademark for the term “Face ID,” it probably won’t get sued. Of course, the company is no stranger to lawsuits, and has arguably been sued on shakier grounds than this, so we’ll just have to wait and see.
- Why Apple Inc.'s Next iPad Pro Won't Be Delayed Due to Chip Yields Stock’s Earning Overview: Apple Inc. Here Are the Suppliers Powering the iPhone X iPhone Sales Data Keeps Apple Inc. (AAPL) on Top Apple Inc. Tries To Woo New Buyers By Selling Old-Gen iPhones In India Apple Inc. Receives “In-line” Rating From Piper jaffray Companies How Costly Will the Apple Inc. HomePod Delay Be? Apple Inc. To Open First Store In Korea By End Of 2017